Checking MVT hypotheses with a vertical tangent
Consider the function on the closed interval .
The function is continuous everywhere, including on . Compute and use it to determine whether is differentiable at every point of the open interval . Based on this, does the Mean Value Theorem guarantee the existence of a point such that ? State your conclusion and justify it using the hypotheses of the MVT.
Hint
Differentiate using the power rule, then check whether the resulting expression is defined at every point in , especially near .
Step-by-step solution
Differentiating gives . This expression is undefined at because it involves division by zero, even though is perfectly well-defined. Graphically, this corresponds to a vertical tangent line at , since as .
Since lies inside the open interval , fails to be differentiable at every point of , so one of the two hypotheses of the MVT (differentiability on the open interval) is not satisfied. Therefore the MVT does not guarantee the existence of such a point — the theorem simply does not apply here (it may or may not still be true, but MVT gives no guarantee).
Related problems
Practice similar Calculus problems interactively.
Start Closing the Gap