Checking MVT hypotheses for an absolute value function
Consider the function on the closed interval .
The Mean Value Theorem states that if is continuous on and differentiable on , then there exists some in such that .
Consider on .
Explain why the Mean Value Theorem does not guarantee the existence of a point with . In your explanation, identify which hypothesis of the MVT fails and state where on the interval it fails.
Hint
Check both required conditions of the MVT separately: is continuous everywhere on , and is differentiable everywhere on ? Recall that has a sharp corner at .
Step-by-step solution
The function can be written piecewise as for and for . This function is continuous everywhere, including on , since the two pieces meet at with the same value . So the continuity hypothesis of the MVT is satisfied.
However, differentiability fails at : the left-hand derivative is and the right-hand derivative is , so does not exist. Since lies in the open interval , is not differentiable on all of . Because this hypothesis of the MVT fails, the theorem simply does not apply here — it makes no claim about existence of , and indeed no such works, since everywhere it's defined but the secant slope is .
Location of the differentiability failure
Hint
Step-by-step solution
The answer is x equals two. The function f of x equals the absolute value of x minus two has a sharp corner exactly at x equals two, where the left-hand derivative is negative one and the right-hand derivative is positive one. Since these one-sided derivatives disagree, the derivative does not exist at that point. This is the specific location inside the interval where the differentiability hypothesis of the Mean Value Theorem breaks down.
Related problems
Practice similar Calculus problems interactively.
Start Closing the Gap