Checking MVT hypotheses on a discontinuous function
Consider the function on the interval .
Someone claims that since and , the Mean Value Theorem guarantees a number in with . Explain why this application of the MVT is invalid, and identify the specific hypothesis of the theorem that fails for on .
Hint
Check where is defined and continuous on . Does , which lies inside the interval, cause any trouble for continuity or differentiability?
Step-by-step solution
The Mean Value Theorem requires to be continuous on the closed interval and differentiable on the open interval . Here is undefined at , since that makes the denominator zero, and lies inside .
Because is not even defined (hence not continuous, and not differentiable) at , the continuity hypothesis of the MVT fails on . Therefore the theorem simply does not apply here, and no conclusion about the existence of such a can be drawn from it — the computation using and is meaningless in this context.
Indeed, has a vertical asymptote at , splitting the graph into two disconnected branches on , which visually confirms the discontinuity.
Related problems
Practice similar Calculus problems interactively.
Start Closing the Gap