← Back to learning objective

Checking MVT hypotheses on a discontinuous function

Consider the function f(x)=1x−1f(x) = \dfrac{1}{x-1} on the interval [0,3][0,3].

Someone claims that since f(0)=−1f(0) = -1 and f(3)=12f(3) = \dfrac12, the Mean Value Theorem guarantees a number cc in (0,3)(0,3) with f′(c)=f(3)−f(0)3−0f'(c) = \dfrac{f(3)-f(0)}{3-0}. Explain why this application of the MVT is invalid, and identify the specific hypothesis of the theorem that fails for f(x)=1x−1f(x) = \dfrac{1}{x-1} on [0,3][0,3].

Checking MVT hypotheses on a discontinuous function graph
Hint

Check where ff is defined and continuous on [0,3][0,3]. Does x=1x = 1, which lies inside the interval, cause any trouble for continuity or differentiability?

Step-by-step solution

The Mean Value Theorem requires ff to be continuous on the closed interval [a,b][a,b] and differentiable on the open interval (a,b)(a,b). Here f(x)=1x−1f(x) = \dfrac{1}{x-1} is undefined at x=1x=1, since that makes the denominator zero, and 11 lies inside [0,3][0,3].

Because ff is not even defined (hence not continuous, and not differentiable) at x=1∈(0,3)x=1 \in (0,3), the continuity hypothesis of the MVT fails on [0,3][0,3]. Therefore the theorem simply does not apply here, and no conclusion about the existence of such a cc can be drawn from it — the computation using f(0)f(0) and f(3)f(3) is meaningless in this context.

Indeed, ff has a vertical asymptote at x=1x=1, splitting the graph into two disconnected branches on [0,3][0,3], which visually confirms the discontinuity.

Related problems

Practice similar Calculus problems interactively.

Start Closing the Gap