Oscillatory limit failure at x = 1
Consider the function , which is defined for all .
As , the quantity grows without bound in absolute value, so keeps oscillating between and instead of settling near any single value. The graph below illustrates this behavior near .
Does exist? Justify your answer by describing what happens to as approaches from either side, and state which of the standard failure cases (unequal one-sided limits, unbounded growth, or oscillation) applies here.
Hint
Think about how fast changes as gets extremely close to 1, and what cosine does as its input grows without bound. You don't need to compute exact values — consider the pattern of repeated oscillation.
Step-by-step solution
As , the denominator , so takes on arbitrarily large positive and negative values very close to . Since oscillates between and forever as ranges over larger and larger values, cycles repeatedly through all values in infinitely often no matter how close gets to 1.
This means the function never settles down and approaches a single number as ; instead it keeps oscillating without bound-in-input causing bound-in-output settling. This is the oscillation-type failure of a limit (like as ), so the limit does not exist.
Related problems
Practice similar Calculus problems interactively.
Start Closing the Gap