← Back to learning objective

Maximizing cone volume from a circular sector

A cone-shaped cup is made from a flat circular piece of paper of radius R=12R = 12 cm by cutting out a sector and joining the two straight edges of the remaining piece together, so that the remaining sector forms the lateral surface of a cone.

When the sector is folded into a cone, the slant length of the cone equals the radius R=12R = 12 of the original circle, and the base radius rr of the cone depends on how much of the circle's edge remains (i.e., on the arc length of the sector used). Using the Pythagorean relationship between the cone's height hh, base radius rr, and slant height RR, the volume of the cone can be written as a function of rr alone:

V(r)=π3r2R2−r2,0<r<RV(r) = \frac{\pi}{3} r^2 \sqrt{R^2 - r^2}, \qquad 0 < r < R

Find the base radius rr (in cm) that maximizes the volume of the cone, and give the maximum volume VV (in cm3^3).

Hint

Since R=12R = 12 is fixed, treat V(r)=π3r2144−r2V(r) = \frac{\pi}{3}r^2\sqrt{144 - r^2} as a function of the single variable rr. It's easier to maximize V(r)2V(r)^2 (or equivalently work with f(r)=r4(144−r2)f(r) = r^4(144-r^2)) to avoid differentiating a square root, since V≥0V \geq 0 on the domain. Take the derivative, set it to zero, and check the result lies in (0,12)(0,12).

Step-by-step solution

Since V(r)≥0V(r) \geq 0, maximizing V(r)V(r) is equivalent to maximizing g(r)=V(r)2=π29r4(144−r2)=π29(144r4−r6)g(r) = V(r)^2 = \frac{\pi^2}{9} r^4(144 - r^2) = \frac{\pi^2}{9}(144r^4 - r^6). Differentiating with respect to rr: g′(r)=π29(576r3−6r5)=π29r3(576−6r2)g'(r) = \frac{\pi^2}{9}(576r^3 - 6r^5) = \frac{\pi^2}{9} r^3(576 - 6r^2). Setting g′(r)=0g'(r) = 0 gives r=0r = 0 (excluded, endpoint) or 576−6r2=0576 - 6r^2 = 0, so r2=96r^2 = 96, giving r=96=46≈9.80r = \sqrt{96} = 4\sqrt{6} \approx 9.80 cm, which lies in (0,12)(0,12).

Checking that this is a maximum: g′(r)>0g'(r) > 0 for rr slightly less than 464\sqrt{6} and g′(r)<0g'(r) < 0 for rr slightly greater, confirming a maximum (also V→0V\to 0 at both endpoints r=0r=0 and r=12r=12). Substituting r2=96r^2 = 96 into V(r)V(r): 144−96=48=43\sqrt{144 - 96} = \sqrt{48} = 4\sqrt{3}, so V=π3(96)(43)=1283 π≈696.5V = \frac{\pi}{3}(96)(4\sqrt{3}) = 128\sqrt{3}\,\pi \approx 696.5 cm3^3.

Related problems

Practice similar Calculus problems interactively.

Start Closing the Gap