Estimating the limit of an oscillating function near a point
Consider the function . We want to understand what happens to as approaches .
The graph of near is shown below.
As gets closer and closer to (from either side), does approach a single value ? Based on the graph, what can you conclude about ? Give the value of the limit if it exists, or state that it does not exist and briefly explain why.
Hint
Try plugging in a sequence of -values approaching , such as for large integers , and see what values takes. Also look at how densely the graph oscillates as .
Step-by-step solution
As , the quantity grows without bound, so it sweeps through all real numbers infinitely many times, causing to cycle repeatedly between and . For example, choosing gives , while choosing gives . Both of these sequences of -values approach , yet the corresponding values approach two different numbers.
Since we can find -values arbitrarily close to where is as close to as we like, and other -values equally close to where is as close to as we like, never settles down to a single value near . This matches the graph, which shows increasingly rapid oscillation as . Therefore the limit does not exist due to oscillation.
Reason for nonexistence of the limit
Does cosine of one over x fail to have a limit because it oscillates or because it blows up?
Hint
Step-by-step solution
It oscillates. As x approaches zero, cosine of one over x repeatedly cycles between negative one and one without settling on a single value. This is different from a function growing without bound, since the values here stay confined between negative one and one at all times. The graph in part a shows increasingly rapid back-and-forth oscillation near zero, confirming this is the cause of nonexistence.
Related problems
Practice similar Calculus problems interactively.
Start Closing the Gap